//No Amnesty for Women

No Amnesty for Women

[su_divider top=”no” divider_color=”#006699″]
[su_quote cite=”Andrea Dworkin, 1981″]Equality cannot co-exist with rape…..and it cannot co-exist with pornography or with prostitution or with economic degradation of women on any level, in any way….. because implicit in all these things is the inferiority of women.[/su_quote]
Sharing this for the Tri County Women’s Centre
12 Cumberland Street, Yarmouth
Nova Scotia B5A 3K3

Ph: (902) 742-0085
Fax: (902) 742-6068
Toll Free: 1-877-742-0085

Please add your name and your voice!
[su_divider top=”no” divider_color=”#006699″]
Canadian Advocates for the Nordic Model (CANM)

Amnesty International has sought a policy to protect the human rights of women in prostitution who they identify as “sex workers”. The manifesto specifically says that it wishes to decriminalize “all aspects of consensual adult sex work that doesn’t involve coercion, exploitation or abuse.” (1)

Alan Young, counsel for the applicants in the Bedford case told the court that 5, 10 or 20% of the women in prostitution were there by choice. (2) Several studies show that 5 – 10% of women are in prostitution by choice. (3) That means 90-95% of women or 9 out of 10 women are in prostitution not by choice – they are coerced, trafficked or exploited. They cannot leave. They cannot make their own decisions. Does Amnesty still identify these 90% of women as “sex workers”? How does Amnesty International propose to protect the human rights of these 90%?

Amnesty International believes that “prostitution is a human right”. Whose human right is it? The buyers, the pimps, or the sellers?

Decriminalising all aspects of prostitution turns pimps into business managers, johns into customers and prostituted women into workers. If a “worker” has a bad “work experience”, their remedy is to appeal under employment legislation. The police and criminal law is not there to protect her. If she’s assaulted by a “customer”, the customer will claim consent and contract after all, she has agreed to provide sexual relations for money. How are the police to determine whether the “contract” was transgressed? Was it just rough sex? Or maybe ìt would be considered just regular torture perceived as consent for sadomasochism. (4)

As only 5-10% of women are in prostitution willingly without coercion, it follows that the demand exceeds supply by 90%. How does Amnesty International’s proposal provide THESE women with human rights – human right not to be abused, human right not to be tortured, human right to be treated with dignity? Or do THESE women not have human rights?

The only way to protect these women is to decriminalize their involvement in prostitution so that they can freely seek the help of police, social services or other support and to criminalise the abusers – the pimps and the johns. If the acts of selling and buying of woman in prostitution are decriminalised, women have to prove they were coerced, trafficked, exploited or tortured. This is more difficult evidentially. Especially difficult for women tortured as Canada has no specific law that addresses torture perpetrated by private individuals or groups; although it is known that women in prostitution suffer acts of torture. (5,6) Decriminalising the demand for the purchase of women in prostitution will allow for an explosion of brothels and organized crime groups with more vulnerable women being trafficked. Just look at Germany (7) and Australia (8) where there is now no regulation on brothels and foreigners are being brought into the country to “work” in the brothels.


It’s imperative to revisit and cancel this abominable policy and support the Nordic Model. It’s imperative to protect hundreds of thousands of vulnerable women who are in prostitution unwillingly. The only way to do so is to decriminalize them but criminalize the pimps and the johns. Those who choose to enter prostitution, frankly have other choices.

Dated September 11, 2015

This letter with its signatures will forwarded to: Amnesty International 312 Laurier Ave,

Ottawa, ON, K1N 1H9 | info@amnesty.ca

Contact Information: Linda MacDonald & Jeanne Sarson Email: flight@ns.sympatico.ca
Website: www.nonstatetorture.orgg
Mail: 361 Prince Street, Truro, NS, B2N 1E4

1 https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2015/08/sex-workers-rights-are-human-rights/
2 http://www.feminisms.org/3265/the-myths-of-bedford-v-canada-why-decriminalizing-prostitution- won%E2%80%99t-help/
3 http://www.catwinternational.org/Content/Images/Article/234/attachment.pdf
4 Email communication from Data Dissemination Officer Statistics Canada, July 27, 2009.
5 http://www.cbc.ca/bc/news/bc-100820-vancouver-police-pickton-investigation-review.pdf
6 Human Trafficking National Coordination Centre. (2014). Domestic human trafficking for sexual exploitation in Canada October 2013 (p. 22). Ottawa: RCMP.
7 http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/human-trafficking-persists-despite-legality-of-prostitution- in-germany-a-902533-2.html
8 http://www.catwa.org.au/?q=node/37

One Comment

  1. Glen September 30, 2015 at 9:57 am

    Please share this post as well. Amnesty’s position needs to change.

Comments are closed.